A new resident in San Antonio, Ali Conrad wishes she could find an intellectual man. When her dates turn out less than exciting, she emails her sister a list of ten wishes her fantasy man could provide. Her wishes start appearing but anonymously. Ali caught apartment manager Cole Hayden’s eye the day she rented the apartment. Through his computer support business, he spotted her wish list and hopes by fulfilling them he’ll convince Ali to accept a date. Life gets in the way and he’s not present when the wishes arrive, and Ali believes they are from another man. How far will Cole go to convince Ali he’s her secret admirer?